There's something about your post that disagrees with me. Oh sure, it's very logical for the most part. But the bit I've quoted, less so. No-one has the right to say this game is going to suck? You're depriving us of the right to pre-empt the release of the game and voice our opinions?
I disagree. This is a message board, a forum. We come here to discuss things and share opinions. You will get people who say they don't like things, and that can't be stopped. Remember we had people saying "STOP TRASHING ON SONIC NEXT! IT'S NOT RELEASED YET!"
We had people doing the same for Sonic Rivals as well. And Shadow the Hedgehog. And Sonic Riders. And Sonic 1 GBA. And so I will voice my opinion, and say that I do no expect this game to do well. So there.